Paul Newman once described his performance in The Long, Hot Summer as his worst project from the 1950s. This take differs from the public love the picture still receives today. His residence in Connecticut with Joanne Woodward offered a simple luxury that was remarked upon by workers. The couple chose a humble style despite their huge stardom. Director Mike Nichols offered a rare dissenting view on the star's craft. Nichols stated that the actor was decent but not amazing. This note is one of the rare instances where peers questioned his skills. These truths show a man who undervalued his own hit and faced tough criticism. The story details his humility and the varied thoughts peers held of his craft.